GOVT 2306 · Unit 5 (Final)

Executive, Judicial & Criminal Justice

📅 Chapters 9 · 10 · 13 — Final Aug 6–8 (check Blackboard)
📌 Three-chapter final. Watch the contrast pairs the review loves: full vs. conditional pardon, grand jury vs. petit jury, original vs. appellate jurisdiction, who runs county jails (sheriff) vs. who oversees them (Jail Standards Commission), and civil-procedure rules (Supreme Court) vs. criminal-procedure rules (legislature). One ⚠️ trap flagged in LO 10.4 / Ch.13 study guide: the review's "counsel for the poor in civil cases" — there's no such constitutional right; the intended answer is the Sixth Amendment (criminal).

Study Guide

Unit 5 · Chapters 9 · 10 · 13 — 100% review coverage

LO 9.1 — A weak governor & the plural executive

  • Plural executive — Article IV creates a multi-headed executive branch: power is split among several independently elected officials the governor does not control. This is why the Texas governor is a weak (constitutionally limited) executive, unlike the U.S. president.
  • Constitutional qualifications — at least 30 years old, a U.S. citizen, and a Texas resident for the 5 years immediately preceding the election.
  • Term & term limits4-year term; Texas places no term limits on the governor (one of 14 states with none).
  • Appointive power — the governor's single most important formal power: naming supporters/allies to boards and commissions. Limited by: (a) most appointments need two-thirds consent of senators present ("advice and consent"); (b) senatorial courtesy — the governor clears a nominee with the senator from the nominee's home district first.
  • Removal of appointees — the governor may remove his/her own appointees only with two-thirds Senate consent, and cannot remove appointees of a previous governor. So the governor does not have independent removal power.
  • Removing the governor — the only constitutional method is impeachment by the House + conviction by the Senate (like "Pa" Ferguson). 📌 Review: "Is the governor weak or strong? Why?" → weak, because of the plural executive, limited appointment/removal power, a short list of formal powers, and a fragmented bureaucracy.
  • Executive order — a directive the governor issues to state agencies (used, e.g., for emergency/disaster management, as in the March 2020 COVID-19 state of emergency). Governors also use proclamations to call special sessions/elections.

LO 9.2 — Legislative powers (shared with the legislature)

  • Legislative power (overview) — the governor's tools to shape lawmaking: veto, line-item veto, message power, and the special-session call.
  • Veto — reject a whole bill; override needs two-thirds of both chambers (rare, since the session is usually over). After adjournment the governor has 20 days to veto. No pocket veto in Texas — an unsigned bill still becomes law.
  • Line-item veto — strike individual items from the appropriations (budget) bill while approving the rest. This is the governor's strongest legislative/budget weapon and the only significant constitutional budget power the governor has.
  • Message power — the State of the State address and formal messages that set the agenda and build goodwill with legislators.
  • Special sessiononly the governor can call one; up to 30 days; no limit on the number; the governor sets the agenda (legislators may consider only what the governor lists). 📌 Review: "strongest legislative power regarding the legislature" → the veto / line-item veto. "Only significant constitutional budget power" → the line-item veto. Note the Legislative Budget Board (LBB), chaired by the lieutenant governor, actually writes the budget.

LO 9.3 — Powers over the judiciary

  • Judicial appointments — the governor fills vacancies on state (not county or city) courts from death, resignation, or new-court creation; appointees then face the next election.
  • Executive clemency (needs a BPP recommendation): a full pardon restores all civil rights with no conditions; a conditional pardon restores rights but attaches a restriction (e.g., can never again practice a licensed profession). Also commutation (reducing a sentence).
  • Independent death-penalty power — acting alone, the governor may grant one 30-day reprieve (a temporary delay of execution); a full commutation of a death sentence still requires a Board of Pardons and Paroles recommendation. 📌 Review: "power over judges extends to" → filling vacancies on state courts. "In a death-sentence case, what can the governor independently do?" → grant one 30-day reprieve. "Full vs. conditional pardon?" → full = no strings; conditional = rights restored with a restriction.

LO 9.4 — Informal powers

  • Informal powers — influence not in the constitution: leading the state party, using mass/social media to shape opinion and pressure the legislature, and pork-barrel bargaining (trading favors — e.g., promising not to line-item-veto a project in exchange for a vote). Strength depends on popularity and political skill.

LO 9.5 — Resources, succession & removal

  • Succession — the lieutenant governor is first in line if the governorship is vacant, and serves out the term. If both governor and lt. gov. are gone, the acting-governor order is President pro tem of the Senate → Speaker → attorney general → chief justices of the courts of appeals.
  • Military power / commander-in-chief — the governor is Commander-in-Chief of the state's military forces (Texas Army & Air National Guard, Texas State Guard) — except when they are called into federal service. May deploy them for disasters, riots, border operations, etc. 📌 Review: "as commander-in-chief the governor may use the Guard for all of the following EXCEPT ___" → the exception is any power the governor lacks, e.g., using them while they are in federal service or for a purely federal military mission.
  • Law enforcement — the governor is not the state's main cop. In Texas, most law enforcement is done by local police and county sheriffs; the governor's only direct law-enforcement power is to use the Texas Rangers / DPS and call out the Guard in emergencies. 📌 Review: "primary responsibility for enforcing the law" → local police & county sheriffs (not the governor). "Direct law-enforcement power of the governor" → deploy the Texas Rangers/DPS and National Guard in emergencies.

LO 9.6 — Elections & campaign money

  • Campaign funds & appointments — gubernatorial campaigns are costly, so governors rely on big donors; large donors are often appointed to key policymaking positions (legal but criticized). No term limits let incumbents build long fundraising/appointment networks.

LO 9.7 — The plural executive: elected heads + secretary of state

  • Lieutenant governor — elected separately; presides over the Senate, chairs the LBB; often called the single most powerful official in Texas state government. First in line of succession.
  • Attorney general — chief civil lawyer for the state; represents Texas in court, issues advisory opinions, enforces child-support.
  • Comptroller of Public Accounts — chief accounting officer and tax collector; certifies how much revenue is available (the budget must fit within it).
  • Commissioner of the General Land Office — manages state-owned lands and awards oil, gas, and sulfur leases on them.
  • Commissioner of Agriculture & the three elected members of the Railroad Commission (today it regulates the oil & gas industry, not railroads).
  • Secretary of State — the one department head appointed by the governor; the state's chief elections officer. 📌 Review pairs: "single most powerful person in state government" → lieutenant governor. "Chief accounting officer & tax collector" → comptroller. "Awards oil/gas/sulfur leases" → land commissioner.

LO 9.8 — The bureaucracy

  • Sunset Advisory Commission — reviews agencies and recommends whether each be abolished, merged, reorganized, or retained.
  • Texas Education Agency (TEA) — oversees statewide school testing; other key bodies: State Board of Education, TCEQ, Public Utility Commission. Fragmentation means the governor influences more than commands the bureaucracy.

LO 10.1 — Sources of Texas law & types of law

  • Civil law — governs disputes between private parties: contracts, divorce/family issues, personal-injury (tort) claims. The loser typically owes money, not jail time.
  • Criminal law — offenses against the state (the government prosecutes); punishable by fines and/or incarceration.
  • Misdemeanor — a minor offense (Classes C/B/A); punished by fine and/or up to a year in county jail.
  • Felony — a serious offense; punishable by state prison (and possibly a fine). Characteristic: felonies are punishable by a prison sentence and a fine.
  • Common law / judge-made law — legal principles built from individual court decisions; shaped mainly by appellate courts.
  • Statutory law — laws enacted by the legislature.
  • Code — a systematic, subject-by-subject arrangement of statutes. The Texas Legislative Council has been re-codifying Texas law since 1963.
  • Ordinance — a law passed by a local government (city/county). 📌 Review: 1963 Legislative Council project → reorganizing Texas laws into a systematic arrangement of legal codes.

LO 10.2 — The court system & participants

  • The 8 types of Texas courts (low→high): Municipal courts; Justice of the Peace (JP) courts; Constitutional County courts; County courts-at-law; Probate courts; District courts; Courts of Appeals; and the two highest — Supreme Court of Texas and Court of Criminal Appeals.
  • Jurisdiction — a court's authority to hear a particular case. Original jurisdiction = hears a case for the first time (trial). Appellate jurisdiction = reviews a lower court's decision on appeal. Exclusive jurisdiction = only that court may hear it. Concurrent jurisdiction = more than one court may hear the same type of case.
  • Court of record — a court that keeps a full transcript. Most municipal and JP courts are NOT courts of record, so their appeals are heard by trial de novo (a brand-new trial) in a county-level court.
  • Justice of the peace (JP) court — local trial court: small civil claims, minor criminal (Class C) cases, traffic. Small claims court functions were folded into the JP courts (self-represented, low-dollar disputes). 📌 Review: "owed $8,000 and want to represent yourself" → file in the Justice of the Peace (small-claims) court (JP civil jurisdiction up to $20,000).
  • District courts — the principal trial courts; try both civil and criminal cases; exclusive original jurisdiction over felonies, divorce, and land title.
  • Constitutional county court — one per county; limited civil/criminal jurisdiction plus administrative duties (the county judge also runs the commissioners court). County courts-at-law were created to relieve them and hear mostly misdemeanors.
  • Probate — matters of decedents' estates: primarily establishing the validity of a will; probate courts also handle guardianship and mental-competency determinations. 📌 Review: court with original jurisdiction over both a will's validity and mental competency → probate court. Contested will's validity → decided by a probate court.
  • Supreme Court of Texas — highest court for civil (and juvenile) cases; 9 justices, 6-year terms; makes the rules of civil procedure.
  • Court of Criminal Appeals — highest court for criminal cases; death-penalty appeals go directly here. 📌 Review: "court NOT mentioned in the Texas Constitution" → the legislatively created statutory courts (county courts-at-law, municipal courts, statutory probate courts). "Highest civil court" → Supreme Court of Texas; "case appealed directly to the Court of Criminal Appeals" → a death-penalty case.
  • Elected judgesalmost all Texas judges are elected in partisan elections (municipal judges are usually appointed). Critics argue this influences rulings (donors, re-election). District judges can be removed by the voters, by the State Commission on Judicial Conduct, or by impeachment/address.
  • State Bar of Texas — the mandatory organization all licensed Texas attorneys must join; sets professional standards.
  • Grand jury12 citizens chosen from a pool of 20–125; if at least 9 agree there is enough evidence, they return an indictment.
  • Petit jury — the trial jury that decides guilt/liability: 12 members in district court, 6 in lower (county/JP) courts.
  • Venire — the panel/pool of prospective jurors summoned for possible service.
  • Voir dire — the questioning of the venire by judge and attorneys to select (and strike) jurors. 📌 Review numbers: grand jury indicts if ≥9 of 12 agree. Petit juries = 6 or 12 members (12 in district court). Criminal verdict must be unanimous. Are all Texas judges elected? → yes, except municipal (partisan elections).

LO 10.3 — Civil adjudication

  • Plaintiff — the party who files the civil suit. Defendant — the party being sued.
  • Tort — a civil wrong (other than breach of contract), such as a personal-injury or defective-product claim (e.g., the defective-steering-wheel lawsuit = a tort).
  • Remedy — the most common remedy is monetary damages (financial compensation), not jail.
  • How civil cases are tried — most are bench trials (judge decides). If a jury sits, the jury finds the facts and the judge applies the law.
  • Verdict — the jury's finding. Judgment — the court's final written decision that resolves the case.
  • Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) — mediation/arbitration used to settle disputes and relieve crowded dockets without a full trial. 📌 Review: who makes the rules of civil procedure? → the Supreme Court of Texas. Dissatisfied civil party proceeds next to a court of appeals.

LO 10.4 — Criminal adjudication & rights

  • Indictment — the formal instrument (from a grand jury) accusing someone of a felony and ordering them to trial. (A lesser charge can proceed by information.)
  • Constitutional jury rights / rights of the accused — after arrest and before questioning, police must advise a suspect of the right to remain silent and to have an attorney; the accused has the right to appointed counsel if indigent and the right to trial by jury.
  • Unanimous verdict / hung jury — a criminal verdict must be unanimous; if jurors can't agree it's a hung jury → the judge declares a mistrial.
  • Indigent defense — paid mostly by county governments (~90% of the ~$300M cost). Rules of criminal procedure are made by the legislature. 📌 Review: instrument that formally accuses of a felony and orders trial → indictment. Criminal-verdict agreement → all jurors (unanimous). Purpose of jail/prison → punishment, deterrence, incapacitation, and (ideally) rehabilitation.

LO 13.1 — Classifications of criminal offenses

  • Texas Penal Code — the codified body of laws defining crimes and punishments in Texas.
  • Graded penalties — offenses are ranked by seriousness: misdemeanors (Classes C→A) and felonies (state-jail → 3rd → 2nd → 1st degree → capital). Punishment is based on the grade/classification of the offense.
  • Enhanced punishment — punishing an offender as though they had committed the next-higher degree of felony; triggered by organized criminal activity, being a repeat offender, or a hate crime. (Top two hate-crime motivations in Texas: race and sexual orientation.)
  • Capital felony — the most serious class (e.g., killing a police officer during a robbery); punishable by life without parole or death. 📌 Review: "how is punishment based?" → on the graded classification of the offense (plus enhancements). Historic Texas approach to drug offenses → incarceration.

LO 13.2 — The death penalty

  • Capital felony circumstances — murder of a peace officer/firefighter on duty, murder during another felony (robbery, etc.), multiple victims, or a victim under 10.
  • Minimum sentence for a capital felonylife imprisonment without parole (maximum = death).
  • Jury unanimity for death — after a guilty verdict, all 12 jurors must unanimously agree (and find future dangerousness) before a death sentence is imposed.
  • Method & drug supply — execution is by lethal injection; if FDA-approved drugs run short, Texas may get drugs from another state and repay in kind. Texas leads the nation in executions.
  • Moratorium — despite the American Bar Association urging one, Texas legislators have consistently rejected a death-penalty moratorium. 📌 Review: minimum capital sentence → life without parole. Jurors needed for a death sentence → all 12 (unanimous).

LO 13.3 — Jails, prisons & community supervision

  • Texas Department of Criminal Justice (TDCJ) — runs the state prison system.
  • County jailsrun day-to-day by the county sheriff, but the Texas Commission on Jail Standards has oversight responsibility.
  • Private prisons — Texas has more privately operated incarceration facilities than any other state; about 10% of Texas inmates are in private prisons.
  • Two community-supervision agencies (serving a sentence in the community, not prison): the Community Justice Assistance Division (probation/community supervision) and the Parole Division (parole & mandatory supervision) — both within TDCJ.
  • Recidivism — relapse into criminal behavior that returns a released offender to prison (release in June, re-arrested robbing a bank in December = recidivism).
  • Administrative segregation — long-term solitary confinement (death-row inmates are held this way the whole time); criticized as violating international human-rights standards and the U.S. Constitution.
  • Prison problemsovercrowding and staff shortages drive both inmate-on-inmate violence and use of force by officers; lack of air conditioning; the most common contraband is now the cell phone. 📌 Review: oversight of county jails → Texas Commission on Jail Standards; who directs most county jails → the county sheriff. % inmates in private prisons → ~10%. Two community agencies → Community Justice Assistance Division + Parole Division.

LO 13.4 — Juvenile justice

  • Age of adulthood — in Texas, criminal adulthood begins at 17.
  • Adjudication hearing — the term for a trial in juvenile court; juvenile courts are civil, not criminal, so appeals go to a court with civil jurisdiction (ultimately the Texas Supreme Court).
  • Status offenders vs. delinquentsstatus offenders commit acts illegal only because of age (running away, truancy, curfew violations); delinquent children commit acts that would be crimes for an adult.
  • Texas Juvenile Justice Department (TJJD) — created in 2011 (via sunset review) to replace the abolished Texas Youth Commission and Texas Juvenile Probation Commission. 📌 Review: juvenile offenders handled under → juvenile (civil) courts via adjudication hearings. Agency that replaced TYC/TJPC → Texas Juvenile Justice Department.

LO 13.5 — Fairness, exoneration & reform

  • DNA testing — the scientific development that has exonerated people convicted of serious crimes, including murder.
  • Eyewitness testimony — the least reliable evidence yet the most trusted by juries; a leading cause of wrongful convictions.
  • Compensation — Texas pays the wrongfully incarcerated $80,000 for each year imprisoned.
  • Texas Forensic Science Commission — investigates charges of negligence and misconduct related to DNA/forensic evidence.
  • Racial profiling — targeting members of historically marginalized groups for stops and searches; a core fairness concern.
  • Who prosecutes — the district attorney (DA) represents the State of Texas in criminal cases. The plea bargain is the principal short-term method for relieving overcrowded court dockets. 📌 Review: scientific development freeing the innocent → DNA testing. Who represents the State in criminal cases → the district attorney. Short-term docket relief → plea bargaining. ⚠️ Review Ch.13: "Which amendment guarantees legal representation to the poor in civil cases?" — there is no constitutional right to counsel in civil cases; the Sixth Amendment (via Gideon v. Wainwright, 1963) covers criminal cases. Answer the intended item as the Sixth Amendment, but the "civil" wording is imprecise. Sourced externally / logic-checked against the chapters' indigent-criminal-defense coverage.

Flashcards

Question
Answer

Practice Quiz

Discussion Board Prep

Notes Template

Unit 5 · Chapters 9 · 10 · 13 — print this tab for study notes

📺 Ch. 13 Videos (from the Ch. 10 lecture deck)

⚠️ These two links are embedded on slide 3 of the Ch. 10 lecture deck (labeled "Death penalty" / "Lethal injection"). They map to Ch. 13's death-penalty material. Titles shown are the deck's labels — the linked video content was not independently verified in this build.

Plural Executive (9.7)

Governor's Legislative Powers (9.2)

Clemency: Pardon / Reprieve (9.3)

Jurisdiction Types (10.2)

Grand vs. Petit Jury (10.2/10.4)

Civil vs. Criminal Procedure (10.3/10.4)

Graded / Enhanced Penalties (13.1)

Death Penalty Process (13.2)

Corrections & Recidivism (13.3)

Juvenile vs. Adult (13.4)

Fairness / Exoneration (13.5)

Contrast Pairs to Drill